When identical functional groups are not identical: A DFT study of the effects of molecular environment on sulfur K-edge X-ray absorption spectra

Density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT (TD-DFT) calculations have been used to elucidate differences in the sulfur K-edge spectra of three pairs of related compounds: methionine and S ( Me ) 3 + , cystine and (±)6-thioctic amide, and (Me)2SO3 and (CH2)2SO3. TD-DFT is shown to accurately reproduce all the experimental XAS spectra. The 2 eV energy difference in the sulfur K-edge rising edge position between methionine and trimethylsulfonium is shown to derive from changes in bonding rather than the increase in effective nuclear charge. A similar insensitivity to effective nuclear charge is found in the XAS spectra of cystine and (±)6-thioctic amide. These surprising results are traced back to the fact that XAS spectra reflect orbital energy differences, rather than a measure of the atomic potential. The change in atomic potential following oxidation or reduction affects the core and valence orbitals almost equally. In all cases DFT calculations showed that the dramatic differences in sulfur K-edge spectra found between functional groups in alternative molecular environments derive from the variations in orbital mixing and energies following from bonding. However, XAS rising-edge energy positions have a near linear correlation with oxidation state. This is attributed to the fact that bond strength typically increases with oxidation state. Therefore, although XAS rising-edge energies are an approximate measure of the oxidation state of the absorbing atom, it is important to recognize that the correlation of XAS edge energy with effective nuclear charge is not direct. This result is finally applied to the question of quantitative sulfur speciation in complex materials of chemical, biological, or geological origin.