Sufficient criteria are necessary for monotone control volume methods

Control volume methods are prevailing for solving the potential equation arising in porous media flow. The continuous form of this equation is known to satisfy a maximum principle, and it is desirable that the numerical approximation shares this quality. Recently, sufficient criteria were derived guaranteeing a discrete maximum principle for a class of control volume methods. We show that most of these criteria are also necessary. An implication of our work is that no linear nine-point control volume method can be constructed for quadrilateral grids in 2D that is exact for linear solutions while remaining monotone for general problems.