Developmental autonomy and somatic niche construction promotes robust cell fate decisions

During the course of development cells undergo division producing a variety of cell types. Proliferation and differentiation are dependent on both genetic programs, encoded by the cellular genome, and environmental cues produced by the local cellular environment imposing local selection pressures on cells. We explore the role that cellular signals play over a large range of potential parameter regimes, in minimizing developmental error: errors in differentiation where an inappropriate proportion of differentiated daughter cells are generated. We find that trophic factors produced by the population of dividing cells can compensate for increased error rates when signals act through a form of positive feedback—survival signals. We operationalize these signals as the somatic niche and refer to their production as somatic niche construction. We find that tissue development switches to an autonomous state, independent of cellular signals, when errors are unmanageably high or density regulation is very strong. A signal-selective regime—strong niche dependence—is favored at low to intermediate error, assuming compartmentalized density dependence.