Chaos and parametric management

A number of people provided helpful comments and suggestions during the preparation of this reply. None of them, of course, bear responsibility for any mistakes or conclusions drawn here. They were: Michael Fogarty, Lloyd Dickie, David Feeney, Spencer Apollonio, Ted Ames, Robin Alden, Richard Langton, Peter Auster, Stephanie Watson, and Raymond OʹConnor. We are grateful to the Sea Grant Program of the Universities of Maine and New Hampshire and the Resource and Property Rights Program of the Beijer Institute for the valuable resources.