Time and space in stratigraphy: The ‘3-m gap’ story

Even for earth scientists it appears difficult to keep in mind that a sedimentary succession does not form due to accumulation at a constant rate, but that long periods of slow accumulation may alternate with short phases of event sedimentation and/or shorter or longer time-spans of non-deposition or even erosion. An example of this incorrect way of thinking is a recently published article in which it is postulated that the find of a ceratopsian brow horn only 13 cm below the K/T boundary in the Hell Creek Formation (Montana, USA) proves that dinosaurs did not become extinct before the K/T impact. It is argued why the postulated consequence (closure of the so-called 3-m gap: a zone of some metres thick underneath the K/T boundary in which, thus far, no dinosaur remnants had been found in the USA) is based on incorrect presumptions, particularly the relationship between time and space.