Reserve price commitments in auctions

It is well known that the optimal auction-one that maximizes the sellerʹs expected revenue-can be implemented using a standard auction format with a suitably chosen reserve price. This reserve price is above the sellerʹs value of retaining the object and the mechanism requires a commitment not to sell the object below the reserve. This commitment is what makes the reserve valuable to the seller. However, in practice, a reserve price commits the seller to sell the object if the reserve is reached, but does not commit her to withhold the object from sale if bidding falls short of the reserve. In this note we investigate whether reserve prices remain valuable for the seller when she may negotiate with the highest bidder if the reserve is not met. We show that the value of the reserve price may be completely undermined if the seller is a sufficiently weak bargainer.