The Validity and Clinical Utility of the MMPI–2 Malingering Depression Scale

In this study, we examined the validity and clinical utility of the MMPI–2 (Butcher, Graham, Tellegen, Dahlstrom, & Kaemmer, 2001) Malingering Depression scale (Md) in relation to the MMPI–2 F scales (F, FB, FP) to detect feigned depression. Overall, the FB scale and the F/FP scale combination were the best single predictors, although the Md scale did discriminate successfully cases of feigned depression from patients with bona fide depression. The Md scale added predictive capacity over the F scales, and the FB scale and the F/FP scale combination added predictive capacity over the Md scale; however, the actual increase in the number of cases predicted was minimal in each instance. In sum, although the Md scale is able to detect accurately feigned depression on the MMPI–2 (predictive validity), it does not confer a distinct advantage (incremental validity) over the existing standard validity scales—F, FB, and FP.