Evaluation of subcooled critical heat flux correlations for tubes with and without internal twisted tapes Original Research Article

Eleven correlations and models for critical heat flux (CHF) of subcooled flow boiling in water were evaluated. Both a direct substitution method (DSM) and a heat balance condition method (HBM) were compared in the evaluations. The HBM was recommended as a better prediction method in the present study. For straight tubes under uniform heating conditions, the correlations of the Gunther, Knoebel, modified Tong, W-2, and Tong-75, and also the Celata and Weisman-Pei models were confirmed to give reasonably good predictions. Among them, the Celata model was the best with respect to accuracy. For swirl flow under uniform heating conditions. Tong-75-I (involving modification of the water velocity parameter) and Nariai-Inasaka correlations were confirmed to give reasonably good predictions, even though their predictions were too low for the CHF under non-uniform heating conditions.