• DocumentCode
    1394042
  • Title

    Comment on “Differential Evolution as Applied to Electromagnetics”

  • Author

    Anyong Qing

  • Author_Institution
    Temasek Labs., Nat. Univ. of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore
  • Volume
    53
  • Issue
    4
  • fYear
    2011
  • Firstpage
    169
  • Lastpage
    171
  • Abstract
    In the paper being commented upon, "an overview of differential evolution-based approaches used in electromagnetics" is presented. It is my great pleasure to note from the paper that my works on differential evolution have been well appreciated by fellow researchers in the electromagnetics community. However, facts presented in the paper are inadequate and views given in the paper are inaccurate. As such, the presented overview is neither complete nor accurate. The authors are also not aware of some of the serious misconceptions of evolutionary computation in the community. Consequently, the paper is misleading and might lead to unexpected disastrous consequences.
  • Keywords
    electromagnetic field theory; differential evolution; disastrous consequences; electromagnetics community; evolutionary computation; Differential equations; Electromagnetic radiation;
  • fLanguage
    English
  • Journal_Title
    Antennas and Propagation Magazine, IEEE
  • Publisher
    ieee
  • ISSN
    1045-9243
  • Type

    jour

  • DOI
    10.1109/MAP.2011.6097316
  • Filename
    6097316