Real-Time Optical Flow Calculations on FPGA and GPU Architectures: A Comparison Study

FPGA devices have often found use as higher-performance alternatives to programmable processors for implementing a variety of computations. Applications successfully implemented on FPGAs have typically contained high levels of parallelism and have often used simple statically-scheduled control and modest arithmetic. Recently introduced computing devices such as coarse grain reconfigurable arrays, multi-core processors, and graphical processing units (GPUs) promise to significantly change the computational landscape for the implementation of high-speed real-time computing tasks. One reason for this is that these architectures take advantage of many of the same application characteristics that fit well on FPGAs. One real-time computing task, optical flow, is difficult to apply in robotic vision applications in practice because of its high computational and data rate requirements, and so is a good candidate for implementation on FPGAs and other custom computing architectures. In this paper, a tensor-based optical flow algorithm is implemented on both an FPGA and a GPU and the two implementations discussed. The two implementations had similar performance, but with the FPGA implementation requiring 12× more development time. Other comparison data for these two technologies is then given for three additional applications taken from a MIMO digital communication system design, providing additional examples of the relative capabilities of these two technologies.