The functions of multiple singing modes: experimental tests in yellow warblers, Dendroica petechia

In several groups of songbirds, including the North American wood warblers (Parulidae), males subdivide their song repertoires into two different categories, or ‘modes’, of singing. Previous studies of wood warblers suggest that the two singing modes in this group are each specialized for interacting with one of the two sexes: Type 1 singing for interacting with females and Type 2 for interacting with other males. Here I examine the responses of male and female yellow warblers to the two singing modes produced by males. Using song playback experiments, I found that male yellow warblers responded to potential intruders with Type 1 singing, rather than Type 2 singing, as predicted. In tests using the copulation solicitation assay, females implanted with oestradiol responded equally strongly to both Type 1 and Type 2 singing. These results suggest that male wood warblers use both singing modes to interact with males and females, and that the singing modes do not have distinct, sex-specific functions as previously thought. Factors other than intra- and intersexual selection are therefore likely to have helped shape the evolution of distinct singing modes.