Acoustic communication in a duetting grasshopper: receiver response variability, male strategies and signal design

In the duetting grasshopper Chorthippus biguttulus, a femaleʹs decision to reply to a conspecific male is based on the evaluation of a number of features of the maleʹs song, which consists of uninterrupted syllables separated by pauses. Female responses are tuned to a restricted range of pause durations. However, males produce songs with noisy rather than silent pauses, which should make the measurement of pause durations more difficult for the female. We examined the adaptive value of these noisy pauses by testing female responses to (1) pairs of natural phrases, which differed only with respect to clear or noisy syllable pauses, and (2) synthetic phrases, in which the syllable onset accentuations and noise levels in the pauses were systematically varied. There was considerable variation between females, both in their preference for clear or noisy pauses in natural phrases, and in the optimal combinations of syllable onset accentuations and noise levels in pauses that they preferred in synthetic phrases. The response profiles of individual females were consistent. The experiments with synthetic phrases showed that, on average, females preferred more extreme values of syllable onset accentuations than were present in male songs. Noisy pauses increased the range of syllable pause durations accepted by females. The results suggest that noisy pauses could buffer signallers against the negative consequences of both signal degradation during transmission and extreme receiver choosiness.