Effect of vegetation on runoff-sediment yield relationship at different spatial scales in hilly areas of the Loess Plateau, North China

Whether vegetation reduces soil loss by reducing runoff volume or rather by changing runoff-sediment yield relationship has received little attention. Base on the observed data from monitoring stations and the published data from other research, this issue is addressed at different scales in hilly areas of the Loess Plateau, North China. At the plot scale, vegetation helps reduce soil loss not only by reducing runoff volume, but also by changing the runoff-sediment yield relationship, resulting that the sediment-reduction rate is higher than the runoff-reduction rate. At the watershed scale, gully erosion and mass wasting process are dominant. Vegetation measures are insufficient to control local mass movement, implying that sediment availability remains high even after vegetation is established. It is also hard for slope vegetation to change the capacity of the sediment transport system at the watershed scale. Therefore, vegetation cannot change the runoff-sediment yield relationship at the watershed scale. This implies that vegetation reduces sediment yield only by reducing runoff volume and the sediment-reduction rate approximates the runoff-reduction rate at the watershed scale. Other slope measures for soil conservation such as terraces are considered to have the same effect on the runoff-sediment yield relationship as the vegetation. Several case studies involving different spatial scales are presented and confirm this conclusion.