Organic fouling of forward osmosis membranes: Fouling reversibility and cleaning without chemical reagents

The recently resurgent forward osmosis (FO) membrane process has the potential to become a sustainable alternative to conventional membrane processes. However, the fouling and cleaning behavior of FO membranes remains largely unknown. There is a need to fully understand the fouling phenomena in FO in order to take advantage of this emerging technology. In this study, we used alginate as a model organic foulant to examine FO membrane fouling and cleaning behavior with the ultimate goal of determining the underlying FO fouling/cleaning mechanisms. Results showed that alginate fouling in FO is almost fully reversible, with more than 98% recovery of permeate water flux possible after a simple water rinse without any chemical cleaning reagents. We also studied the role of applied hydraulic pressure in membrane fouling and cleaning by performing fouling tests in FO (without hydraulic pressure) and RO (with hydraulic pressure) modes. Flux recovery in the FO mode was much higher than that in the RO mode under similar cleaning conditions, although the rate of membrane flux decline was similar in the two modes. The fouling reversibility of FO was attributed to the less compact organic fouling layer formed in FO mode due to the lack of hydraulic pressure. Our results suggest that operating in FO mode may offer an unprecedented advantage in reducing or even eliminating the need for chemical cleaning. AFM force measurements were used to elucidate the impact of membrane materials (cellulose acetate versus polyamide) on membrane fouling and cleaning behavior. Adhesion force data revealed that a small percentage of relatively adhesive sites on the membrane surface play an important role in increasing membrane fouling potential and decreasing cleaning efficiency. This finding implies that using average adhesion force to predict membrane fouling potential is inadequate. Extensive long-range adhesion forces are observed for the polyamide membrane in the presence of alginate and calcium ions. The long-range interactions are attributed to calcium bridging of alginate molecules between the AFM probe and the adhesive sites on the polyamide membrane surface.