Title of article :
How to derive an advantage from the arbitrariness of the g-index
Author/Authors :
Schreiber، نويسنده , , Michael، نويسنده ,
Issue Information :
فصلنامه با شماره پیاپی سال 2013
Abstract :
The definition of the g-index is as arbitrary as that of the h-index, because the threshold number g2 of citations to the g most cited papers can be modified by a prefactor at oneʹs discretion, thus taking into account more or less of the highly cited publications within a dataset. In a case study I investigate the citation records of 26 physicists and show that the prefactor influences the ranking in terms of the generalized g-index less than for the generalized h-index. I propose specifically a prefactor of 2 for the g-index, because then the resulting values are of the same order of magnitude as for the common h-index. In this way one can avoid the disadvantage of the original g-index, namely that the values are usually substantially larger than for the h-index and thus the precision problem is substantially larger; while the advantages of the g-index over the h-index are kept. Like for the generalized h-index, also for the generalized g-index different prefactors might be more useful for investigations which concentrate only on top scientists with high citation frequencies or on junior researchers with small numbers of citations.
Keywords :
g-Index , Generalized g-index , H-INDEX , citation analysis , evaluation
Journal title :
Journal of Informetrics
Journal title :
Journal of Informetrics