Effect of different surface treatments and coatings on the scuffing performance of hardened steel discs at very high sliding speeds

The paper describes the results of scuffing experiments using a high speed two disc rig, in which a range of different surface treatments and coatings was investigated. The rig used is capable of simulating the operation of heavily loaded gear contacts in terms of maximum Hertzian contact pressure (up to 1.7 GPa), temperature (100 °C oil feed), and sliding speed (up to 25 m/s). The reference scuffing performance was that of axially ground case-carburised or nitrided steel discs having a surface finish of 0.4 μm Ra. The different surface conditions were as follows. The ground discs were superfinished to less than 0.1 μm Ra using a proprietary polishing method. Two different super-hard coatings were investigated. The main conclusions to be drawn from the work are: nitrided surfaces are superior to case-carburised surfaces, but it is essential to remove the compound layer (‘white layer’) to achieve durability at high sliding speeds. The benefits of superfinishing are clearly demonstrated; this improves the scuffing performance and also gives lower friction and bulk temperatures. Hard coatings show promise, and the triple combination of nitriding, superfinishing and hard coating gave particularly impressive scuffing resistance in these tests.