Lack of coordination of nonverbal behaviour between patients and interviewers as a potential risk factor to depression recurrence: vulnerability accumulation in depression

Background: Coordination of nonverbal behaviour during interactions is a prerequisite for satisfactory relationships. Lack of coordination may form a risk factor for depression. The ‘vulnerability-accumulation hypothesis’ assumes that vulnerability to recurrence of depression will increase with increasing experience of depressive episodes. Therefore it is expected that interviewers and patients remitted from a recurrent episode of depression would reach less coordination during a clinical interview compared to interviewers and patients remitted from a first lifetime episode. Moreover, we assumed that prior severity of depression modifies this reciprocal coordination process. Methods: During discharge interviews, interviewers were videotaped in interaction with remitted patients with unipolar major depression recurrent depression (REC); n=28; first episode (SEP); n=22. Durations and frequencies of nonverbal involvement behaviour was registered during the first 15 min. Involvement of the patients consisted of gesticulating, looking at the interviewer, and general head movements; yes - nodding and hm, hm, yes, yes reflected involvement of the interviewer. Coordination between patients and interviewers was analyzed per 3-min epochs and defined as ‘attunement’: the absolute difference between patients’ and interviewers’ involvement. Averaged attunement, its time course and variability (presumably reflecting control of the attunement process) were assessed. Results: The time course of nonverbal attunement differed between the REC and SEP condition. A larger variability of attunement was found in patients remitted from a relatively severely depressed episode, compared to patients remitted from a severe first life time episode. No other significant differences were found. Conclusions: Partial support was found for the notion that nonverbal vulnerability accumulates in depression and that the severity of prior depression modifies this process.