The Active Site of Phosphorylating Glyceraldehyde-3-Phosphate Dehydrogenase Is Not Designed to Increase the Nucleophilicity of a Serine Residue

Changing a catalytic cysteine into a serine, and vice versa, generally leads to a dramatic decrease in enzymatic efficiency. Except a study done on thiol subtilisin, no extensive study was carried out for determining whether the decrease in activity is due to a low nucleophilicity of the introduced amino acid. In the present study, Cys149 of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase fromBacillus stearothermophiluswas converted into a Ser residue. This leads to a drastic reduction of thekcatvalue. The rate-limiting step occurs before the hydride transfer step. Selective, but slow, inactivation is observed with specific, structurally different, inhibitors of serine protease. The esterolytic activity of serine mutant towards activated esters is also strongly decreased. The rate-limiting step of the esterase reaction also shifts from deacylation in the wild type to acylation in the mutant. Altogether, these results strongly suggest that the low catalytic efficiency of the Ser mutant is due to a poor nucleophilicity of the hydroxyl serine group within the active site of the enzyme. The fact that (1) the apo → holo transition does not change esterolytic and inactivating efficiencies, and (2) Ser149 Asn176 double mutant exhibits the same chemical reactivity and esterolytic catalytic efficiency compared to the Ser149 single mutant indicates that the serine residue is not subject to His176 general base catalysis. A linear relationship between the catalytic dehydrogenase rate, thekcat/KMfor esterolysis, and the concentration of OH−is observed, thus supporting the alcoholate entity as the attacking reactive species. Collectively this study shows that the active site environment of GAPDH is not adapted to increase the nucleophilicity of a serine residue. This is discussed in relation to what is known about Ser and Cys protease active sites.