The right person? the right place? the right time? a pilot study of the appropriateness of nursing home placements

The appropriate use of health services is a key challenge for the NHS. Older people have been consistently identified as being disproportionately represented amongst those defined as ‘inappropriately’ located within the acute health sector. Prior to the introduction of community care it was hypothesised that older people were entering nursing home care inappropriately. With the requirement for assessment prior to entry into nursing homes now a feature of the system such ‘inappropriate’ admissions should not occur. This pilot study investigates the feasibility of determining inappropriate admissions and the extent of this phenomenon in nursing homes used by three inner London Boroughs. To determine the number of ‘inappropriate’ placements in nursing homes in three London Boroughs (Lambeth, Southwark & Lewisham). Retrospective audit of nursing home case notes using standardised data collection method. New local authority funded admissions to nursing homes from LSL during the period 1 April 1993–31 March 1995. One hundred and fifty seven people entered the 25 nursing homes identified. For 65% nursing home placement was appropriate, 14% were apparently more suited to residential care and 17% for community care. Documentation concerning clients held by the nursing homes was generally poor. Despite the introduction of the Community Care Act and the clear requirement for assessment before entry into nursing home care, approximately one-third of the placements reviewed were inappropriate and did not meet the individual’s care needs. Further research is underway to determine if these findings apply nationally.