Electron pencil-beam redefinition algorithm dose calculations in the presence of heterogeneities

The electron pencil-beam redefinition algorithm (PBRA) is currently being refined and evaluated for clinical use. The purpose of this work was to evaluate the accuracy of PBRAcalculated dose in the presence of heterogeneities and to benchmark PBRA dose accuracy for future improvements to the algorithm. The PBRA was evaluated using a measured electron beam dose algorithm verification data set developed at The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center. The data set consists of measurements made using 9 and 20 MeV beams in a water phantom with air gaps, internal air and bone heterogeneities, and irregular surfaces. Refinements to the PBRA have enhanced the speed of the dose calculations by a factor of approximately 7 compared to speeds previously reported in published data; a 20 MeV, 15×15 cm2 field electron-beam dose distribution took approximately 10 minutes to calculate. The PBRA showed better than 4% accuracy in most experiments. However, experiments involving the low-energy (9 MeV) electron beam and irregular surfaces showed dose differences as great as 22%, in albeit a small fractional region. The geometries used in this study, particularly those in the irregular surface experiments, were extreme in the sense that they are not seen clinically. A more appropriate clinical evaluation in the future will involve comparisons to Monte Carlo generated patient dose distributions using actual computed tomography scan data. The present data also serve as a benchmark against which future enhancements to the PBRA can be evaluated.