Reflecting onreflection: a personal encounter

This paper reports a retrospective studyof a Senior Lecturer in Nursing Studies experience of supervising a student teacher who, as part of her teaching placement experience, utilised ‘Critically Reflective Analysis of an Educational Event’ as a means to assess her teaching in the practice setting. The Senior Lecturer and student nurse teacher used an external ‘advisor’ to facilitate their meta-reflection on the theoretical perspectives that informed the process in which they were engaged. The paper raises the following questions for consideration — What is the link between ability to reflect and quality of practice? Is it possible to utilise reflective tutorials as a means of assessing-professional competence whilst at the same time encouraging personal and professional development? Is the ability to reflect on practice dependent on the context? Should we assume that all practitioners have the necessary skills to supervise students in practice and what preparation and support is needed? The paper demonstrates that by introducing ‘Critically Reflective Analysis of an Education Event’ into the student teachersʹ curriculum the role of both supervisor and student teacher was challenged and changed. The paper also demonstrates that reflective tutorials are not wholly a retrospective business. They are creative, or recreative of a teaching experience, as well as to some extent representing it. Finally, even if one cannot speak in Kuhnian parlance, of a conceptual revolution, it would seem legitimate to say, in Schonʹs terms, that the contextual frame in which professional problems are addressed has undergone significant change.