Estimating common parameters in heterogeneous random effects models

A question of fundamental importance for meta-analysis of heterogeneous multidimensional data studies is how to form a best consensus estimator of common parameters, and what uncertainty to attach to the estimate. This issue is addressed for a class of unbalanced linear designs which include classical growth curve models. The solution obtained is similar to the popular DerSimonian and Laird (1986) method for a simple meta-analysis model. By using almost unbiased variance estimators, an estimator of the covariance matrix of this procedure is derived. Combination of these methods is illustrated by two examples and are compared via simulation.