Analytical models and laboratory measurements of the soil–tool interaction force to push a narrow tool through JSC-1A lunar simulant and Ottawa sand at different cutting depths

Excavation equipment for developing NASA’s lunar outpost must be carefully designed to reduce launch cost, minimize operation cost, and enhance reliability. Excavation equipment requires knowledge of the stresses and strains in the equipment caused by the forces experienced during excavation. The types of excavation anticipated indicate that blade tools would move the most material. There are several analytical models available to predict forces from blade tools interacting with soil; however, it is not clear which if any, can predict lunar excavation forces precisely enough. Consequently, we measured the forces to push narrow (2.5-cm wide) square and round rods through a control material, Ottawa sand, and JSC-1A lunar mare regolith simulant at different cut depths in a controlled laboratory setting. The measurement results were compared with the forces predicted by eight analytical models. The Zeng, Luth and Wismer, and the Qinsen and Suren models fit the measurements best, considering that our study was limited to pushing stimulant and sand with small rods. The results show that depth of cut has a dramatic effect on the soil–tool interaction forces. Consequently, lunar missions should use a series of shallow cuts to reduce equipment size and power requirements.