The origins and evolution of the North American grassland biome: the story from the hoofed mammals

The North American grassland biome first appeared around 18 Ma in the mid Miocene. The familiar story of the Neogene evolution of this biome is of the replacement of ungulates (hoofed mammals) having a primarily browsing diet by the more derived grazing ungulates. However, new data show a more complicated pattern of faunal succession. There was a maximum taxonomic diversity of ungulates at 16–14 Ma, including a large number of grazers, and the subsequent decline in overall diversity was largely due to the decline of the browsers, with little corresponding increase in the grazers. Additionally the mid Miocene faunas (∼18–12 Ma) contained a much greater number of browsers than any comparable present-day habitat. We discuss possible explanations for these non-analogous grassland faunas, including the possibility that the primary productivity of the vegetation was greater in the early to middle Miocene than it is today. One possible explanation for increased primary productivity is higher Miocene levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide than in the present day. The proposed difference in vegetational productivity also may explain why horses radiated as the main grazers in North America, in contrast to the radiation of antelope in the Plio–Pleistocene African grasslands.