Contributions of coniferous and broad-leaved species to temperate forest carbon uptake: a bottom-up approach

Changes in forest species composition could influence ecosystem carbon uptake rates. To understand how species differed in their contributions to canopy photosynthesis, we investigated how the dominant coniferous (eastern hemlock, Tsuga canadensis (L.) Carr.) and broad-leaved (northern red oak, Quercus rubra L.; red maple, Acer rubrum L.) species in a central Massachusetts forest differed in canopy carbon uptake rates. We considered what factors influenced in situ leaf-level photosynthesis and then used a bottom-up summation approach to estimate species-specific total canopy carbon uptake rates. Variation in canopy light strongly influenced leaf-level photosynthetic rates: sunlit leaves had significantly higher rates than shaded leaves, and photosynthesis increased with canopy height. Species also differed in leaf-level photosynthetic rates, with the broad-leaved species having up to twofold higher rates than hemlock. Within hemlock, needles older than 2 years had lower photosynthesis than younger needles. Variation in leaf-level photosynthesis scaled up to influence canopy carbon uptake rates. Red oak consistently had the highest canopy photosynthetic rates, while through the season, hemlockʹs relative contribution to carbon flux increased and that of red maple decreased. Thus, in such mixed forests, future changes in species composition could have substantial impacts on forest carbon dynamics, particularly if red oak is the primary broad-leaved species to expand at the expense of hemlock.