An Independent Assessment of the Load/Unload Response Ratio (LURR) Proposed Method of Earthquake Prediction

The Load/Unload Response Ratio (LURR) method is a proposed technique to predict earthquakes that was first put forward by YIN (1987). LURR is based on the idea that when an area enters the damage regime, the rate of seismic activity during loading of the tidal cycle increases relative to the rate of seismic activity during unloading in the months to one year preceding a large earthquake. Since earth tides generally contribute the largest temporal variations in crustal stress, it seems plausible that earth tides would trigger earthquakes in areas that are close to failure (e.g., VIDALE et al., 1998). However, the vast majority of studies have shown that earth tides do not trigger earthquakes (e.g., VIDALE et al., 1998; HEATON, 1982; RYDELEK et al., 1992). In this study, we conduct an independent test of the LURR method, since there would be important scientific and social implications if it were proven to be a robust method of earthquake prediction. SMITH and SAMMIS (2004) undertook a similar study and found no evidence that there was predictive significance to the LURR method. We have repeated calculations of LURR for the Northridge earthquake in California, following both the parameters of X.C. YIN (personal communication) and the somewhat different ones of SMITH and SAMMIS (2004). Though we have followed both sets of parameters closely, we have been unable to reproduce either set of results. Our examinations have shown that the LURR method is very sensitive to certain parameters. Thus it seems likely that the discrepancies between our results and those of previous studies are due to unaccounted for differences in the calculation parameters. A general agreement was made at the 2004 ACES Workshop in China between research groups studying LURR to work cooperatively to resolve the differences in methods and results, and thus permit more definitive conclusions on the potential usefulness of the LURR method in earthquake prediction.