A theoretical analysis of the contributions of remodeling space, mineralization, and bone balance to changes in bone mineral density during alendronate treatment

In patients with osteoporosis, alendronate treatment causes an increase in bone mineral density (BMD) and a decrease in fracture incidence. Alendronate acts by changing the bone remodeling process. Changes in bone remodeling resulting in decreased remodeling space, increased bone balance per remodeling cycle, and increased mineralization (ash mass/bone mass) have all been associated with alendronate treatment. Understanding the relative contributions of these parameters to BMD increases could help predict the utility of long-term (>10 years) or intermittent treatment strategies, as well as treatment strategies in which another pharmaceutical is administered concurrently. We have developed a computer simulation of bone remodeling to compare the contributions of focal bone balance and mineralization on BMD by simulating alendronate treatment using a bone balance method (decreased remodeling space, increased focal bone balance, uniform bone mineralization) and a mineralization method (decreased remodeling space, neutral focal bone balance, varying bone mineralization). Although both methods are able to predict BMD increases caused by alendronate over short periods, our findings suggest that the mineralization method may be more descriptive of long-term alendronate treatment. This implies that mineralization may be a larger contributor to BMD changes caused by alendronate than the focal bone balance. Based on this finding we offer a hypothesis to describe how remodeling space, focal bone balance, and mineralization each contribute to alendronate-induced BMD changes. Future analyses with this method could be used to identify improved dosing regimens and to predict which osteoporosis treatments would best complement each other.