Mandibular fracture osteosynthesis: a comparison of three techniques

The authors report on a retrospective study of 205 consecutive patients at the Maxillofacial Unit of The Royal Melbourne Hospital to assess if adherence to Champyʹs principles in placement of miniplates in mandibular fractures minimises morbidity. 205 well documented cases of mandibular fractures treated with internal fixation, January 1985 to April 1990 were studied. The patients were assigned into three groups according to the type of fixation; 83 patients had miniplate fixation according to Champyʹs principles, 40 patients had miniplate fixation ignoring Champyʹs principles, 82 patients had transosseous wire (TOW) fixation. Outcome was measured by preoperative variables (age, gender, mechanism of fracture, site and number of fractures, nerve function, associated injuries and treatment delay) and postoperative variables (duration of admission, duration of intermaxillary fixation (IMF), malocclusion, infection, dehiscence, union, removal of fixation and nerve function which were assessed and compared. The results show that the preoperative variables were statistically similar in all groups. The postoperative variables indicated a statistically higher complication rate for the transosseous wire group compared with the miniplate groups, and morbidity was reduced in the group following champyʹs principles. The morbidity rates in this study compare favourably with other studies even though the patients in this study had a much higher incidence of multiple fractures. Titanium miniplates appear as effective as miniplates constructed of other materials used in previous studies, especially when Champyʹs principles are followed.