Audit of a conservative management policy of the axilla in elderly patients with operable breast cancer

Between April 1982 and February 1994, 344 women aged >70 years with cancers <5 cm in diameter were treated at the City Hospital Breast Unit. The majority were enrolled in two successive randomized trials.1–3 One hundred and sixty patients had primary therapy with tamoxifen alone and were subsequently treated with mastectomy if the primary cancer progressed. Fifty-three women with a high oestrogen receptor (ER) status in the tumour received mastectomy and postoperative tamoxifen. One hundred and thirty-one patients underwent primary surgery (104, mastectomy; 27, wide local excision) and did not receive adjuvant tamoxifen. Only the 184 (131 + 53) patients who underwent primary definitive surgery have been included in this study. Patients undergoing primary surgery without palpable lymph nodes (n = 159) did not undergo axillary exploration. Twenty-five women who were noted pre-operatively to have clinically palpable lymph nodes underwent excision of obviously enlarged lymph nodes in the axilla in addition to primary surgery; small nodes that measured less than around 1 cm were left in place. None received axillary clearance or axillary irradiation. The median follow-up is 54 months. Twenty-three of 159 (14%) patients without palpable nodes, and four of 25 (16%) with palpable nodes, have subsequently developed axillary recurrence. Grade 3 tumours were associated with a higher rate of regional recurrence. Regional relapse was treated successfully with different therapeutic modalities (surgery, radiotherapy or endocrine manipulation) and none have died from uncontrolled regional disease.