Evaluation of soft tissue reactions to three nonabsorbable suture materials in a rabbit model

Objectives: We evaluated the inflammatory reactions in¬duced by three commonly used nonabsorbable suture ma-terials in a rabbit model. Methods: Three suture materials were tested: braided polyester suture (Ethibond), braided blend of polyester and polyethylene suture (FiberWire), and monofilament poly¬propylene suture (Polypropylene). Thirty-six rabbits were randomly allocated to three suture groups, equal in number. Each suture type was placed bilaterally in the quadriceps muscle, patellar tendon, knee joint capsule, and Achilles tendon. Six animals in each group were sacrificed in the third and sixth weeks. The inflammation induced by each suture was assessed using light microscopy and the width of the inflammation zone (WIZ) was measured. Results: Ethibond was found to cause the most severe reaction in the muscle and tendon in the third week; in the sixth week, however, it showed the lowest inflammatory reaction in all tissue types. Reaction to Propylene was moderate in the third week, whereas it caused the largest WIZ in all tissue types in the sixth week, such that the eventual size of the WIZ induced by Propylene (6.6±2.1 mm) was significantly greater than that of Ethibond (1.6±0.9 mm) in muscle specimens (p<0.05). Ex¬cept for the largest WIZ seen in joint capsule specimens in the third week, inflammatory reactions associated with Fiber- Wire were low or moderate in all tissue specimens through¬out the study. FiberWire was associated with some necrotic areas in two muscle and one tendon specimens. Conclusion: The extent of inflammatory reaction to nonab-sorbable suture materials depends on the type of suture ma¬terial, tissue type, and the duration of postoperative time.