Excised or intact inflorescences? Methodological effects on parasitoid wasp longevity

The development of accurate and repeatable experimental techniques is a cornerstone of any research program. Indeed, the first stage in developing a conservation biological control program typically involves ranking the suitability of various plant species as food resources for the target species of natural enemy in the laboratory or glasshouse. Herein the choice of flower presentation method is a highly relevant consideration. It is unclear whether excised flowers with their peduncles submerged in water will generate similar effects on the life history traits of a natural enemy compared with those using flowers remaining intact on a rooted plant. Either method has been used in 86 previous studies, yet none has quantified this effect. It is possible that both plant nectar content and production are altered as a result of changes in the physiological condition of the excised flowers. A laboratory test was designed to assess the influence of flower presentation method (excised or intact inflorescences) and different types of nectar (artificial and natural) on the longevity of the wasp Aphidius ervi, an important parasitoid of aphids. Distinct differences were revealed in the suitability of the nine flower species and three control treatments on parasitoid wasp longevity, with buckwheat being the most suitable plant. However, apart from coriander, flower presentation method and wasp gender generally did not affect parasitoid longevity for the set of species tested. As there was little evidence that parasitoid wasp longevity would be altered on excised flowers, and because of reasons pertaining to improved logistical and experimental requirements, the use of excised flowers is cautiously recommended to researchers for further laboratory evaluations of the effects of nectar provision on parasitoid fitness.