Using quantitative real-time PCR to study competition and community dynamics among Delaware Inland Bays harmful algae in field and laboratory studies

The Delaware Inland Bays (DIB) have experienced harmful algal blooms of dinoflagellates and raphidophytes in recent years. We used quantitative polymerase chain reaction (QPCR) techniques to investigate the community dynamics of three DIB dinoflagellates (Karlodinium veneficum, Gyrodinium instriatum, and Prorocentrum minimum) and one raphidophyte (Heterosigma akashiwo) at a single site in the DIB (IR-32) in summer 2006 relative to salinity, temperature and nutrient concentrations. We also carried out complementary laboratory culture studies. New primers and probes were developed and validated for the 18S rRNA genes in the three dinoflagellates. K. veneficum, H. akashiwo, and G. instriatum were present in almost all samples throughout the summer of 2006. In contrast, P. minimum was undetectable in late June through September, when temperatures ranged from 20 to 30 °C (average 25.7 °C). Dissolved nutrients ranged from 0.1 to 2.8 μM PO43− (median = 0.3 μM), 0.7–30.2 μM NOx (median = 12.9 μM), and 0–19.4 μM NH4+ (median = 0.7 μM). Dissolved N:P ratios covered a wide range from 2.6 to 177, with a median of 40. There was considerable variability in occurrence of the four species versus nutrients, but in general P. minimum and H. akashiwo were most abundant at higher (>40) N:P ratios and dissolved nitrogen concentrations, while K. veneficum and G. instriatum were most abundant at low dissolved N:P ratios (<20) and dissolved nitrogen concentrations < 10 μM. The semi-continuous laboratory competition experiment used mixed cultures of K. veneficum, P. minimum, and H. akashiwo grown at dissolved N:P ratios of 5, 16, and 25. At an N:P of 16 and 25 P. minimum was the dominant alga at the end of the experiment, even at a temperature that was much higher than that at which this alga was found to bloom in the field (27 °C). P. minimum and H. akashiwo had highest densities in the N:P of 25. K. veneficum grew equally well at all three N:P ratios, and was co-dominant at times at an N:P of 5. H. akashiwo had the lowest densities of the three algae in the laboratory experiment. Laboratory and field results showed both interesting similarities and significant differences in the influences of important environmental factors on competition between these harmful algal species, suggesting the need for more work to fully understand HAB dynamics in the DIB.