Abstract :
This essay examines restorative justice scripting in Voices, the second
volume of Ursula K. Le Guin’s ‘‘Annals of the Western Shore.’’ Narrated by a rapechild,
Voices is the story of an occupied city-state and of how the conquered and the
conquerors negotiate a formula for peaceful coexistence. They are able to do so by
enacting a restorative justice script. Their use of the mediation of an outsider, the
wandering poet Orrec, is not unlike the use of trained mediators in victim-offender
mediation programmes that operate within the restorative justice paradigm. The
steps envisioned by justice scripting in Voices correspond to five general elements
of the restorative justice encounter as outlined in Capeheart and Milovanovic’s
model. Finally, the resolution of the conflict in the novel is centrally concerned with
the reintegration of victims and offenders, involving the elements of a successful
resolution in the restorative justice paradigm: apology, behavioural change, restitution
and generosity. Generalizing from the example of Voices, it is argued that, in
their capacity to generate ideas and feelings about justice, works of fantasy and
science fiction evoke and provide what Schank calls ‘‘scripts,’’ thus inviting readersto consider justice imperatives in the real world by means of the cognitive scripting
of acts in the fictional worlds.
