Spatiotemporal variation of breeding gull species in a boreal lake complex in Finland: Implications for conservation Original Research Article

Understanding spatial and temporal patterns of species is a prerequisite for successful species and habitat conservation. Spatial variation in breeding sites of four gull species was studied in southern Finland in an oligo-mesotrophic lake complex covering almost 50 km2 of water areas and 290 km of shoreline in three census periods in 1986–2004. Two of the species have declined and are regarded as red-listed in Finland (black-headed gull ridibundus and lesser black-backed gull L. f. fuscus) and two have increased (common gull L. canus and herring gull L. argentatus) in numbers during the past decades. The numbers of breeding pairs and the percentage similarity in the spatial distribution of pairs of each species in grid squares were compared between different census periods at resolutions of 0.25, 1 and 4 km2. The common gull showed very high percentage similarity between the different census periods and consequently low spatial turnover in nesting sites, whereas the red-listed species, particularly the black-headed gull, had much higher spatial turnover. The spatiotemporal dynamics of gull species should thus be taken into account in conservation planning. If site protection is based only on information of breeding gulls in one year, a large or even major proportion of the breeding red-listed gulls might be outside the protected areas after a few decades. Due to the large spatiotemporal variation of red-listed gulls, areas to be protected should cover a rather large proportion of a boreal lake, not only individual islets or islands.