About “On certain incomplete statistics” by Lima et al.

Lima et al. recently claim that (Chaos, Solitons & Fractals 19 (2004) 1005) the entropy for the incomplete statistics based on the normalization ∑ipiq=1 should be S=−∑ipi2q−1lnqpi instead of S=−∑ipiqlnqpi initially proposed by Wang. We indicate here that this conclusion is a result of erroneous use of temperature definition for the incomplete statistics.