Assaying the effects of chemical ameliorants with earthworms and plants exposed to a heavily polluted metalliferous soil

The study examined the effects of chemical ameliorant additions (1% montmorillonite, 1% hydroxylapatite, or 1% ferrous oxide) on the availability of cadmium (Cd), copper (Cu), lead (Pb) and zinc (Zn) to the earthworm, Lumbricus rubellus, exposed for 4 weeks to a circumneutral heavily polluted soil (Cd = 220 μg g–1; Cu = 35 μg g–1; Pb = 6070 μg g–1; Zn = 124500 μg g–1) in 1:0–1:3 dilutions with a clean soil, under laboratory conditions. Soil type (i.e. the dilution series) had a strong influence on the 1 M ammonium acetate extractable metal fractions in soil and on worm-tissue concentrations of Cd, Pb and Zn. Soil treatments (i.e. amelioration) significantly reduced only the soil Zn extractable fraction; Zn concentrations in worms tended to be lower in amended soils. A second experiment, involving curly cress (Lepidium sativum), grown either directly in the serial soil dilutions with 5% ameliorant additions or in the water-extractable fractions of the soils, indicated that root growth is a more sensitive endpoint of metal availability than chlorophyll assays. It was concluded that: (i) chemical immobilization of metals is probably most effective in soils with low to moderate degrees of metal pollution; (ii) an integrated suite of bioassays incorporating different, ecologically relevant, taxa is to be recommended for monitoring metal bioavailabilities and biological effects.