Study of Solving the Coordination Curve Intersection of Inverse-Time Overcurrent Relays in Subtransmission Systems

This paper presents a practical and effective novel approach to solve the coordination problem caused by the curve intersection of overcurrent relays in subtransmission systems. Based on the IEEE and IEC standard characteristic curve equations of digital overcurrent relays, as well as the simulation curve equation for electromagnetic overcurrent relays, lever setting adjustment equations for a selected point on the characteristic curve is derived. Then, centered on the derived equations, a dedicated software program is developed to compute the corresponding relay lever setting with different tap value in order that, passing through the selected point, another curve with the new lever setting is chosen. Finally, assisting with the graphical capability of the commercial ASPEN OneLiner, the proposed fixed-point coordination curve adjustment procedure can completely eliminate the coordination curve intersections. In addition, an actual case of a subtransmission network in Taiwan Power Company is simulated to validate the feasibility of the technique proposed.