Title :
Comments on "Spheroidal vector wave eigenfunction expansion of dyadic Green\´s functions for a dielectric spheroid" [with reply]
Author :
Dudley, D.G. ; Johnson, W.A. ; Li, L.W. ; Leong, M.S. ; Kooi, P.S. ; Yeo, T.S.
Author_Institution :
Dept. of Electr. & Comput. Eng., Univ. of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, USA
Abstract :
Dudley and Johnson (see ibid., vol.50, p.XX XX, Nov. 2002) comments that Li, Leong, Kooi and Yeo (see ibid., vol.49, p.645-659, April 2001) formulate in detail the dyadic Green\´s functions for the dielectric spheroid stating that one result of their derivations, the singularity of the electric Green\´s dyadics is extracted. They also comment that there is nothing formally wrong with extracting the delta function. They object strongly, however, to the authors stating that they have extracted "the singularity of the electric Green\´s dyadics." They have not done so. Li et. al. reply that they, are grateful for the comments of Dudley et. al clarifying the singular behavior of the electric and magnetic field Green\´s dyadics. They intended to state "irrotational part of the electric dyadic Green\´s function" which is highly singular, but misused the term, "singularily of the dyadic Green\´s function".
Keywords :
Green´s function methods; dielectric bodies; eigenvalues and eigenfunctions; electric fields; integral equations; magnetic fields; wave functions; delta function; dielectric spheroid; dyadic Green´s functions; electric Green´s dyadics singularity; electric field Green´s dyadics; integral equations; magnetic field Green´s dyadics; spheroidal vector wave eigenfunction expansion; Antennas and propagation; Dielectrics; Eigenvalues and eigenfunctions; Electromagnetic scattering; Electromagnetic wave absorption; Green´s function methods; Integral equations; Maxwell equations; Optimized production technology; Perfectly matched layers;
Journal_Title :
Antennas and Propagation, IEEE Transactions on
DOI :
10.1109/TAP.2002.804025