• DocumentCode
    1226358
  • Title

    Proof of M12=M21 based on stored energy is incorrect

  • Author

    Lin, Pen-Min

  • Author_Institution
    Sch. of Electr. Eng., Purdue Univ., Lafayette, IN, USA
  • Volume
    36
  • Issue
    9
  • fYear
    1989
  • fDate
    9/1/1989 12:00:00 AM
  • Firstpage
    1153
  • Lastpage
    1158
  • Abstract
    The mutual inductances for a pair of coupled coils are described by a single parameter M instead of two parameters M 12 and M21. Correct proofs of M 12=M21 can be found in books on physics, electromagnetic field theory, and circuit theory written decades ago. In recent years, some authors of textbooks for introductory linear circuit analysis have presented an alternative proof which is seemingly simple, but is actually unsound. The flaw of the proof is shown and a proof based on the calculation of the average power is presented
  • Keywords
    coils; inductance; average power calculation; coupled coils; mutual inductances; stored energy; Books; Circuit analysis; Circuits and systems; Coils; Couplings; Electromagnetic field theory; Magnetic circuits; Magnetic fields; Physics; Voltage;
  • fLanguage
    English
  • Journal_Title
    Circuits and Systems, IEEE Transactions on
  • Publisher
    ieee
  • ISSN
    0098-4094
  • Type

    jour

  • DOI
    10.1109/31.34660
  • Filename
    34660