A Study of Consistent and Inconsistent Changes to Code Clones

Code cloning is regarded as a threat to software maintenance, because it is generally assumed that a change to a code clone usually has to be applied to the other clones of the clone group as well. However, there exists little empirical data that supports this assumption. This paper presents a study on the changes applied to code clones in open source software systems based on the changes between versions of the system. It is analyzed if changes to code clones are consistent to all code clones of a clone group or not. The results show that usually half of the changes to code clone groups are inconsistent changes. Moreover, the study observes that when there are inconsistent changes to a code clone group in a near version, it is rarely the case that there are additional changes in later versions such that the code clone group then has only consistent changes.