Comparison of the EKF and the IMM estimator for HFSWR tracking applications

In many applications, the interacting multiple model (IMM) estimator provides better performance over the single model Kalman filter (KF). However, there are two high frequency surface wave radar (HFSWR) factors which seem to make the IMM estimator less attractive: Firstly, the radar has a very long integration time, up to a few hundred seconds for ship detection; Secondly, the radar has very limited detection capability of maneuvering targets. It is unknown whether the IMM estimator will perform better over an EKF for real time HFSWR. The purpose of this paper is to compare the EKF with the IMM estimator. An optimal noise level and critical value have been found for HFSWR EKF design. The results demonstrated that the IMM estimator does not yield improved performance.