Lightpath-Level Protection versus Connection-Level Protection for Carrier-Grade Ethernet in a Mixed-Line-Rate Telecom Network

Ethernet is a success story in Local Area Networks (LAN). Efforts for extending its boundaries beyond LAN to the carriers´ backbone networks are in progress. We study the problem of designing reliable and cost-efficient high-rate (100 Gbit/s) carrier-grade Ethernet in a multi-line-rate telecom network under signal transmission-range constraints. Reliability is achieved using shared-path protection at two levels: (1) Protection-at-Connection (PAC) level, or (2) Protection-at-Lightpath (PAL) level. We study the two cases for their impact on network cost and other performance parameters. We construct a graph, called Mixed Topology (MT), using which it is possible to: (1) identify traffic grooming possibilities, (2) select a path which requires the minimum amount of 3R regeneration, and (3) effectively choose the data rate of a lightpath to be established. Our algorithms, tested on the 17-node German network, lead to the following findings: (1) for both PAL and PAC, our MT-based algorithm resulted in lower network cost and higher lightpath utilization compared with other schemes; and (2) in general, PAL incurs slightly higher cost than PAC.