Theory Identity: A Machine-Learning Approach

Theory identity is a fundamental problem for researchers seeking to determine theory quality, create theory ontologies and taxonomies, or perform focused theory-specific reviews and meta-analyses. We demonstrate a novel machine-learning approach to theory identification based on citation data and article features. The multi-disciplinary ecosystem of articles which cite a theory´s originating paper is created and refined into the network of papers predicted to contribute to, and thus identify, a specific theory. We provide a ´proof-of-concept´ for a highly-cited theory. Implications for cross-disciplinary theory integration and the identification of theories for a rapidly expanding scientific literature are discussed.