• DocumentCode
    3312695
  • Title

    Ockhamistic logics and true futures of counterfactual moments

  • Author

    Braüner, Torben ; Hasle, Per ; Øhrstrøm, Peter

  • Author_Institution
    Centre for Philos. & Sci. Theory, Aalborg Univ., Denmark
  • fYear
    1998
  • fDate
    16-17 May 1998
  • Firstpage
    132
  • Lastpage
    139
  • Abstract
    Various Ockhamistic logics are compared, with the aim of making clear the role of true futures of counterfactual moments, i.e. true futures of moments outside the true chronicle. First, we give an account of A.N. Prior´s (1967) original Ockhamistic semantics, where the truth of a formula is relative to a moment and a chronicle. We prove that this is equivalent to a semantics put forward by Thomason and Gupta (1980), where truth is relative to a moment and a so-called chronicle function which assigns a chronicle to each moment. This is the case because true futures of counterfactual moments do not matter in Thomson and Gupta´s semantics. Later, we discuss how two options considered by Belnap and Green (1994) might be formalised. They come about by associating either a chronicle or a chronicle function to be given once and for all. The first of the two options is unable to give an account of certain statements from natural language, and the second option invalidates an intuitively valid formula. We propose a new Ockhamistic semantics where the formula in question is valid, and furthermore, where true features of counterfactual moments are taken into account. Finally, we discuss possible applications within artificial intelligence
  • Keywords
    temporal logic; temporal reasoning; Ockhamistic logics; Ockhamistic semantics; artificial intelligence applications; chronicle function; counterfactual moments; intuitively valid formula; natural language statements; temporal logic; temporal reasoning; true futures; Councils; Counting circuits; Cultural differences; Ear; Logic; Natural languages;
  • fLanguage
    English
  • Publisher
    ieee
  • Conference_Titel
    Temporal Representation and Reasoning, 1998. Proceedings. Fifth International Workshop on
  • Conference_Location
    Sanibel Island, FL
  • Print_ISBN
    0-8186-8473-9
  • Type

    conf

  • DOI
    10.1109/TIME.1998.674142
  • Filename
    674142