Using TSVs for thermal mitigation in 3D circuits: Wish and truth

3D technology is envisioned to offer advanced integration capabilities, enabling heterogeneous system integration and offering improved performance and reduced power consumption thanks the so-called Through Silicon Vias (TSVs). Nevertheless, 3D integration is facing strong thermal issues due to its higher power density and reduced heat dissipation properties. In previous studies, it has been often reported the use of TSV insertion techniques for thermal mitigation in 3D stacked circuits. However, due to the thin oxide layer isolating TSVs from silicon substrate, the expected thermal mitigation is actually not effective for the current TSV technologies. This paper firstly provides an analytical study to project the potential benefits and drawbacks of using TSVs for thermal mitigation. Detailed FEM simulations and experimental silicon data from a dedicated thermal test chip are then used to confirm the projections and demonstrate that TSVs may even increase the temperature of hotspots. This paper secondly reports the study of the thermal performance of multiple TSV arrays using thermal simulations for various system-level configurations, including a WideIO compatible 3D circuit. Similar results are obtained where, besides not alleviating thermal issues, TSVs may produce exacerbated hotspots. The results presented in this paper indicate that the use of additional area costly TSVs for thermal mitigation is not worthy.