Inter-swarm resource allocation in BitTorrent communities

A considerable body of research shows that Bit-Torrent provides very efficient resource allocation inside single swarms. Many BitTorrent clients also allow users to participate in multiple swarms simultaneously, and implement inter-swarm resource-allocation mechanisms that are used by millions of people. However, resource allocation across multiple swarms in BitTorrent has received much less attention. In this paper, we investigate whether currently prevalent inter-swarm resource allocation mechanisms perform acceptably or call for improvements. We use data from two BitTorrent communities and present results from trace-based simulations. Two use-cases for allocation mechanisms drive our evaluation: (1) file-sharing communities, whose objective is maximizing throughput, and (2) video-streaming communities, whose objective is maximizing the number of users receiving sufficient resources for uninterrupted streaming. To put the results from the analyzed mechanisms into perspective, we devise theoretical efficiency bounds for inter-swarm resource allocation, for which we map the resource allocation problem to a graph-theoretical flow network problem. In this formalism, the goal of the file-sharing use-case, throughput maximization, is equivalent to maximizing the flow in the network. The goal of the video-streaming use-case translates into finding a max-min fair allocation for BitTorrent downloading sessions, a problem for which we devise a new algorithm.