Terrestrial SER characterization for nanoscale technologies: A comparative study

In this work, the efforts of an industry wide consortium to characterize the logic soft error rate of a multitude of combinational and sequential logic circuits across multiple technologies is reported. The basic intent of the approach was to bring together the designs and intellectual property of various semiconductor companies on a single technology platform to be tested and compared under the same experimental conditions. This ensures that the measured results are validated, comparable and benchmarked against other similar designs. More importantly, crucial findings associated with this collaborative effort are also outlined in this paper. Some of the key results include the fact that scaling has led to the steady decline of failure in time (FIT) rates for flip-flops as well as combinational logic circuits. Additionally, the improvement in the soft error resilience provided by redundant node flip-flops has reduced with technology miniaturization due to the effects of charge sharing and multiple node charge collection. In spite of this, however, at high frequencies, the combinational logic soft error rate is comparable to the soft error rate of typical flip-flops. The experimental results are complemented with modeling various soft error mechanisms that affect modern high speed logic circuits.