Abstract :
In a recent paper, Pierce studied the problems of communicating at optical frequencies using photon-counting techniques, and concluded that "at low temperatures we encounter insuperable problems of encoding long before we approach [channel capacity]." In this paper it is shown that even assuming a noiseless model for photon communication for which capacity (measured in nats/photon) is infinite, it is unlikely that a signaling efficiency of even 10 nats/photon could be achieved practically. On the positive side, it is shown that pulse-position modulation plus Reed-Solomon coding yields practical results in the range of 2 to 3 nats/photon.
