Comments on "Finite elements for microwave device simulation: application to microwave dielectric resonator filter" [with reply]

Author

Abramowicz, A. ; Verdeyme, S. ; Guillon, Pierre

Author_Institution

Inst. of Electron. Fundamentals, Warsaw Univ. of Technol., Poland

Volume

41

Issue

4

fYear

1993

fDate

4/1/1993 12:00:00 AM

Firstpage

737

Lastpage

738

Abstract

The commenter raises some questions regarding the results in the above titled paper by J.P. Cousty et al. (ibid., vol.40, no.5, p.925-32, May 1992). He points out a discrepancy that indicates that either the dimensions given in Fig. 4 or the accuracy of the finite element method are in doubt. He also questions the results of applying the 3-D finite element method to the computation of resonant frequencies of hybrid modes. Two of the authors (S. Verdeyme and P. Guillon) defend the results.<>

Keywords

dielectric resonators; finite element analysis; microwave devices; microwave filters; passive filters; simulation; 3D FEM; FEA; finite element method; hybrid modes; microwave device simulation; microwave dielectric resonator filter; resonant frequencies; Computational modeling; Dielectric devices; Finite element methods; Microwave devices; Microwave filters; Microwave theory and techniques; Mode matching methods; Rectangular waveguides; Resonant frequency; Resonator filters;

fLanguage

English

Journal_Title

Microwave Theory and Techniques, IEEE Transactions on

Publisher

ieee

ISSN

0018-9480

Type

jour

DOI

10.1109/22.231677

Filename

231677