DocumentCode
999885
Title
Comparison of different methods in computing electrostatic fields
Author
Donazzi, F. ; Luoni, G.
Author_Institution
Società Cavi Pirelli, Milano, Italy
Volume
19
Issue
6
fYear
1983
fDate
11/1/1983 12:00:00 AM
Firstpage
2596
Lastpage
2599
Abstract
The paper aims at comparing two different methods for solving electrostatic field problems. These are: Finite element method and Finite difference method. The comparison of these two methods is performed on a practical design of an electric component and is based on: - mathematical model schematization, starting from the physical model. - automatic description of the mathematical model to the computer - computation times and memory requirements - computation precision in the solution of the example. These two methods have been implemented as different subroutines in the same main program, so that only the bulk of their computing methods is compared and the comparison does not depend on the computer and the programming language. The results show a general equivalence of the two methods, with some advantages to the Finite differences with respect to computation time and Finite elements with respect to precision.
Keywords
Electrostatic analysis; FEM; Finite difference methods; Finite-element method (FEM); Algorithms; Design automation; Electrostatics; Finite difference methods; Finite element methods; Humans; Mathematical model; Permittivity; Physics computing; Sulfur hexafluoride;
fLanguage
English
Journal_Title
Magnetics, IEEE Transactions on
Publisher
ieee
ISSN
0018-9464
Type
jour
DOI
10.1109/TMAG.1983.1062896
Filename
1062896
Link To Document